Ambition without pressure

Growth Mindset for Kids: What Actually Works at Home

What growth mindset really is, what the research found, who it helps, the three things parents do that count, and when persistence is the wrong tool.

Short answer

A growth mindset for kids is the belief that abilities can grow through effort, good strategies and help from others. Three things parents do seem to matter most: react to failure as information, praise the strategy rather than "smart", and pair "not yet" with a next step. Expect small effects: in a national US trial, lower-achieving ninth graders gained 0.10 of a grade point, and higher achievers gained nothing (Yeager et al., 2019).

Illustration of a mother and son at a table, the boy drawing while she points at his page

Maybe a teacher sent home a poster about the power of yet. Maybe your 12-year-old just said "I'm not a math person" and closed the laptop. Is this idea real, and what do you say tonight? Here is what the research found and who it helps.

Want something to do tonight? Jump to four growth mindset activities at home or what to say at each age. For classroom lessons and printables for younger kids, teacher sites cover more; this page is about what the research says and what works at home.

What growth mindset for kids means, and what it does not

Carol Dweck's idea is simple. A child who believes ability can grow reads a hard problem as "not solved yet", not as proof of a limit. In a TED talk she asks: "Are you not smart enough to solve it … or have you just not solved it yet?" (Dweck, TEDxNorrkoping). That is a talk, not data.

The idea started with praise. In Mueller and Dweck's 1998 studies, fifth graders heard "You must be smart at these problems" or "You must have worked hard at these problems". After a failure, the "smart" group showed "less task persistence, less task enjoyment, more low-ability attributions, and worse task performance" (Mueller & Dweck, 1998).

What the research says

In the same paper, 67% of children praised for intelligence then chose easy problems that would make them look smart. Only 8% of effort-praised children did (Mueller & Dweck, 1998).

The limits matter. These were short lab tasks after one sentence of praise. Study 1 had 128 fifth graders; another study had 51 children aged 9 to 11.

Then Li and Bates ran three studies with 624 Chinese children aged 9 to 13. The first closely copied Mueller and Dweck. The manipulation changed one post-failure test "but not … any of the 8 motivation and attribution measures". The other two found no effect, and mindset was unrelated to grades (Li & Bates, 2019). That was one country and one culture.

Dweck's warning: the "false growth mindset"

Dweck later pushed back on how her idea was being used. "Perhaps the most common misconception is simply equating the growth mindset with effort," she wrote in 2015. Kids also "need to try new strategies and seek input from others when they're stuck" (Dweck, 2015).

She calls the poster version "false growth mindset", a term from Susan Mackie: claiming the mindset without practicing it. Her sharpest line: "Want to hide learning gaps from them? Just tell them, 'Everyone is smart!' The growth mindset was intended to help close achievement gaps, not hide them."

She also writes that "we're all a mixture of fixed and growth mindsets." So this is not a trait your child has or lacks. It is a way of reading a setback.

Does growth mindset work? The honest numbers

How to read the numbers: r is how closely two things move together (0 is none, 1 is perfect). d is the size of a program's effect. For scale, in the national trial an effect size of 0.11 meant 0.10 of a grade point: a student with a 2.5 GPA would end up around 2.6.

The big growth mindset studies since 2018: who was studied and what they found
StudyWhoWhat it found
Sisk et al., 2018 (correlations)365,915 studentsMindset and achievement: r = .10. In 58% of results, there was no measurable link.
Sisk et al., 2018 (programs)43 studies, 57,155 studentsAverage effect d = 0.08. Students from low-income homes: d = 0.34, from only 7 effect sizes.
Yeager et al., 2019 (Nature)12,490 US ninth graders, 65 schoolsLower achievers gained 0.10 grade points. Higher achievers: no effect.
Burnette et al., 202353 randomized samplesKids expected to benefit, well-run programs: d = 0.14 for grades, d = 0.32 for mental health.
Macnamara & Burgoyne, 202363 studies, 97,672 studentsd = 0.05, not significant after correcting for publication bias. Best studies: d = 0.02.

What the research says

In the Sisk meta-analysis, the link was stronger in younger students: r = .19 for primary-school children, .15 for adolescents and .02 for adults. The authors warn that the low-income result "should be interpreted with caution" because few effect sizes contributed (Sisk et al., 2018).

The national US trial used two online sessions of about 25 minutes. Among the 6,320 lower-achieving students, grades rose by 0.10 points, an effect size of 0.11. Effects were larger where peers supported taking on challenges. The authors "cannot draw causal conclusions" about that (Yeager et al., 2019). It was a school program, and several authors developed it.

Macnamara and Burgoyne found that "authors with a financial incentive to report positive findings published significantly larger effects" (Macnamara & Burgoyne, 2023).

A rebuttal reanalyzed the data. It found "a meaningful, significant effect of growth mindset" for kids who were struggling or at risk (Tipton et al., 2023). Yeager co-wrote it, so it comes from an interested party. Yeager and Dweck themselves concede that "mindset effects … are meaningfully heterogeneous across individuals and contexts" (Yeager & Dweck, 2020).

Our read

No study shows that a poster changes a child. Scientists argue about something narrower: how big the effect of structured school programs is, and for which kids. If your child is doing fine in school, expect little change in grades. If your child is struggling, the effect looks more real, though still modest. What parents do at home was studied separately, in smaller and mostly correlational work.

Three things parents do that seem to matter

1. React to failure as information

In our view, this is the most useful finding for home. Haimovitz and Dweck found that children's beliefs about intelligence were not related to their parents' beliefs about intelligence. They were predicted by how parents saw failure. Children "can indeed accurately perceive their parents' failure mind-sets but not their parents' intelligence mind-sets" (Haimovitz & Dweck, 2016).

Parents who saw failure as harmful tended to "focus on their children's performance and ability rather than on their children's learning". Parents who saw failure as useful encouraged the child to learn from it or get extra help. Study 1 had 73 parent–child pairs (BPS Research Digest). In a follow-up experiment, over one hundred parents changed how they said they would react to a child's failure. Children were not measured.

Dweck adds that she finds "many parents who endorse a growth mindset, but react to their children's mistakes as though they are problematic or harmful". Their children, she writes, "develop more of a fixed mindset." In practice: when a bad grade comes home, ask "What did this show us? What will you try next?"

2. Praise the strategy, specifically

One study filmed 53 families at home when the children were 14, 26 and 38 months old. The share of praise aimed at the process ("you worked hard") predicted a more growth-oriented outlook at age 7 to 8. Praise of traits ("you're so smart") did not predict later fixed beliefs (Gunderson et al., 2013). It is correlational, small, and about toddlers.

Name what worked: "You drew a picture of the problem, and that helped." Dweck warns against praising "great effort" when nothing was learned. Her alternative: "Let's talk about what you've tried, and what you can try next" (Dweck, 2015).

3. "Not yet", plus a plan

"Yet" works only with a next step: "You can't do it yet. What's the first step?" No study tests this line; it is our suggestion. Our guide to breaking a big goal into steps shows how to find that first step with a child.

Where DreamBig fits. DreamBig, our app, handles one kind of goal: saving for something your child wants. They pick the dream, its price splits into equal squares, and each saving opens one square of the picture. That gives you a low-stakes place to practice the three habits above. A week with no new square is information, not failure: ask "What got in the way? What will you try next?" A square opened by a new plan is a strategy you can name and praise. This is our idea, not a tested program, and it will not change grades.

Growth mindset activities to try at home

These are our suggestions, built on the findings above. Keep them low-stakes, let your child say no, and compare only with their own first try.

Try this at home · one week

  1. Mistake review. Once this week, look at one mistake together, yours or theirs. Ask only "What did this show us?" and "What will you try next?" This is the reaction to failure that Haimovitz and Dweck linked to children's beliefs.
  2. Strategy swap. When your child is stuck, ask them to name the method they used, then pick a different one or someone to ask. Dweck's point: new strategies and help, not effort alone.
  3. Choose-your-challenge. Offer an easy and a harder version of the same task and let them pick. In Mueller and Dweck's study, most kids praised for being smart chose the easy problems. Praise the choice of the hard one, whatever the result.
  4. Visible progress. Keep a simple record of attempts: test 1 and test 2, first draft and second. At the end of the week, ask what changed between them.
Fixed vs growth mindset: what kids hear from parents, and the swap to try
MomentFixed-mindset phraseGrowth-mindset swap
After a success"You're so smart.""Your checking strategy worked."
Effort, nothing learned"Great effort.""What did you try? What's next?"
After a bad grade"We need to get this grade up.""What did the mistake show us?"
When stuck"Just try harder.""Which strategy will you change?"
Comforting"Not everyone's a math person.""This is hard right now. Where's it stuck?"
"I can't do this""Okay, maybe it's just not for you.""Not yet. What's the first step?"
Chart of six phrases parents can swap, such as replacing You're so smart with Your checking strategy worked, with a note that average effects are small
The same six swaps as one picture to save on your phone.

What to say at 8–10, 11–13 and 14–17

The research gives ages, not scripts.

Growth mindset by age: what fits and what to try saying (our suggestions, not tested lines)
AgeWhat fitsTry sayingWhat the studies covered
8–10Comment on the action right after it happens. Keep strategies concrete. Skip lectures about the brain."You drew a picture of the problem. That's why it clicked."The original praise studies used fifth graders, mean age 10.7.
11–13Teach that a strategy can be swapped. Model your own mistakes out loud."My first plan didn't work. Here's what I'm switching to."A mental-health mindset trial used ages 12 to 15.
14–17Use their own data. Let them choose the challenge. Peers count."What changed between test 1 and test 2?"The national trial was with ninth graders; effects were larger where peers backed challenge.

What the studies covered: the praise studies used fifth graders (mean age 10.7), a mental-health trial used ages 12 to 15, and the national trial used ninth graders.

At 8 to 10, short and specific beats long and inspiring. At 11 to 13, let them hear you get something wrong and change tack. At 14 to 17, teens resist slogans; since peer norms seemed to matter in the national trial, a goal set with a friend may carry more weight than your pep talk. That is our inference, not a finding.

What does not work, and why

The poster or one magic phrase. Across all students, structured school programs average about d = 0.05 to 0.08. A phrase on the fridge is not a program, and no study has tested one on its own.

Effort alone. "Try harder" with the same method is the misconception Dweck named first. It is just repetition.

Saying the right words while looking alarmed. Kids read your reaction to failure, not your stated beliefs. This mismatch is what Dweck calls false growth mindset.

"Everyone is smart." It feels kind, but it can hide a gap that needs teaching.

Expecting it to lift a high achiever's grades. In the national trial, higher-achieving students showed no grade effect. A child who already does well may need a harder challenge, not a mindset talk. For the related idea of sticking with long goals, see what grit in children is.

When persistence is the wrong tool

"Keep going" helps a child stuck on a hard skill. It does not help an anxious child, or one with a learning difficulty nobody has spotted.

Worry, low mood or avoidance

The National Institute of Mental Health lists warning signs. Among them: kids who "Often seem fearful or worried", unexplained stomachaches, or a recent decline in grades. If such signs "last weeks or months" and interfere with home, school or friends, "you should contact a health professional" (NIMH). "Try harder" does not treat anxiety.

Structured mindset programs do have a clinical role. In one trial, 96 high-risk adolescents aged 12 to 15 had a single 30-minute session about how personality can change. Nine months later, parents reported less depression (d = .60) and anxiety (d = .28), and teens reported less depression (Schleider & Weisz, 2018). It was a small, structured program that adds to care, not a pep talk.

A learning difficulty

If your child keeps struggling despite good strategies and support, ask the school for an evaluation. The NICHD notes that "students who are struggling in school can also have individual evaluations." These can include a medical exam and "academic and psychological testing" (NICHD).

The wrong goal

Sometimes the growth move is switching the strategy, or dropping the goal. Our piece on whether to let your child quit helps you tell a hard patch from a bad fit. If the pattern is quitting at the first difficulty, start with what to do when a child gives up easily. If the setback stings more than it teaches, helping kids handle disappointment comes first.

Key takeaways

  • A growth mindset is believing abilities can grow through effort, strategy and help. Effort alone is not it.
  • Average effects on grades are small; they are bigger for kids who are struggling.
  • Your reaction to your child's failures seems to matter more than your beliefs about intelligence.
  • When worry, avoidance or falling grades last for weeks, persistence is the wrong tool. Get help.

Frequently asked questions

What is a growth mindset for kids?

It is the belief that abilities can be developed through effort, new strategies and asking for help when stuck.

Does growth mindset actually work?

A little, on average. School programs average d = 0.08 in one meta-analysis and d = 0.05 in another. Effects are larger for lower-achieving, low-income and at-risk students.

Who benefits most from growth mindset?

In the national US trial, lower-achieving ninth graders gained 0.10 grade points and higher achievers gained nothing. A low-income effect of d = 0.34 rests on only 7 effect sizes, so treat it with caution.

Is praising effort enough?

No. Dweck calls equating growth mindset with effort the most common misconception. Praise the strategy, then plan the next one.

What is the most important thing parents can do?

Watch how you react to your child's failures. In one study, children picked up their parents' view of failure, not their parents' beliefs about intelligence.

When should I stop pushing persistence?

When worry, avoidance or falling grades last weeks, talk to a health professional. When learning stays hard despite good strategies, ask the school for an evaluation.

This article is general information, not medical, psychological or educational advice for a specific child. If your child shows lasting worry, low mood or a drop in grades, talk to your pediatrician or a licensed professional. If learning stays hard despite support, ask the school about an evaluation.

Sources

  1. Mueller, C. M. & Dweck, C. S. (1998). Praise for intelligence can undermine children's motivation and performance. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 75(1).
  2. Gunderson, E. A., Gripshover, S. J., Romero, C., Dweck, C. S., Goldin-Meadow, S. & Levine, S. C. (2013). Parent Praise to 1- to 3-Year-Olds Predicts Children's Motivational Frameworks 5 Years Later. Child Development, 84(5).
  3. Haimovitz, K. & Dweck, C. S. (2016). Parents' Views of Failure Predict Children's Fixed and Growth Intelligence Mind-Sets. Psychological Science, 27(6).
  4. Sisk, V. F., Burgoyne, A. P., Sun, J., Butler, J. L. & Macnamara, B. N. (2018). To What Extent and Under Which Circumstances Are Growth Mind-Sets Important to Academic Achievement? Two Meta-Analyses. Psychological Science, 29(4).
  5. Yeager, D. S. et al. (2019). A national experiment reveals where a growth mindset improves achievement. Nature, 573.
  6. Burnette, J. L. et al. (2023). A systematic review and meta-analysis of growth mindset interventions: For whom, how, and why might such interventions work? Psychological Bulletin, 149(3–4).
  7. Macnamara, B. N. & Burgoyne, A. P. (2023). Do growth mindset interventions impact students' academic achievement? A systematic review and meta-analysis with recommendations for best practices. Psychological Bulletin, 149(3–4).
  8. Tipton, E., Bryan, C., Murray, J., McDaniel, M., Schneider, B. & Yeager, D. S. (2023). Why Meta-Analyses of Growth Mindset and Other Interventions Should Follow Best Practices for Examining Heterogeneity: Commentary on Macnamara and Burgoyne (2023) and Burnette et al. (2023). Psychological Bulletin, 149(3–4).
  9. Dweck, C. (2015). Carol Dweck Revisits the 'Growth Mindset'. Education Week, September 23 (reprint).
Ilya Makarov

Ilya Makarov is the founder of DreamBig, a visual savings-goal app for kids and teens. DreamBig Parenting articles separate what research shows from our interpretation and from practical experiments, and link every source. This article is general information, not medical, psychological or financial advice for a specific child.